Book Review: When a Nation Forgets God by Erwin W. Lutzer

Title: When a Nation Forgets God
Author:
 Erwin W. Lutzer
Publisher: Moody Press

George Santayana (along with numerous other philosophers over the centuries) said, “Those who do not learn from the past are condemned to repeat it.” By understanding the past, you can see the trends that lead to specific trends that transform a culture—for good or for evil.

In When a Nation Forgets God, Erwin W. Lutzer takes this sentiment to heart, revealing to readers seven societal trends that led to the rise of Nazi Germany, and how Christians should respond.

Considering Trajectory

The purpose of this book is not to fuel anyone’s political agendas, nor is it saying that America today is like Nazi Germany or ever will be. Rather, with great skill, tact and wisdom, Lutzer is showing readers the importance of trajectory—in particular, showing where certain trends could lead America, though, as he stresses, not necessarily would.

As religious faith is increasingly privatized, particularly with regard to Christian belief and practice—as church and state are increasingly separated, laws creep in that actually circumvent justice and morality. Freedom of speech is lost in the name of political correctness and a confused view of tolerance. As economies melt down, people can become increasingly willing to give up their civil liberties in exchange for comfort. Media is increasingly used to define the cultural norms of society and sets the moral boundaries. Public school systems increasingly take over the role of training children from parents and in the process have the potential to indoctrinate them with groupthink.

These are the techniques that Hitler used to gain control of Germany. An economically crushed nation, desperate for some glimmer of hope latched onto what it perceived to be a strong leader, one who promised to give the people their national pride back. And he did. In the process, he systematically took complete control of the creation of civil law, made it government-sponsored education compulsory (homeschooling was illegal), turned the people against the Jews, put laws into place that made it not only legal, but acceptable, to murder them.

In essence, he sought to create a Germany in his own image, after his own likeness.

Parallels

Today, there are some parallels in America, according to Lutzer, and as a Canadian it is fascinating to read his concerns. “Political correctness has now affected the general culture and created an aura of censorship and a climate of fear,” he writes on page 27. In addressing the recently approved hate crimes legislation, Lutzer writes,

The bottom line is that we are going down a dangerous path as “hate crimes” are linked to “hate speech” and thus our First Amendment rights are curtailed. . . . From “Hate Crimes” the next step is for the courts to prosecute those who are deemed guilty of “Hate Speech,” which one of our senators called “domestic terrorism.” Thus, what we think and what we say are both open to prosecution. Hate speech in this country will mean . . .  simply stating an opinion that the government thinks should not be expressed. (p. 28)

In Canada, we’re already there. The Canadian Human Rights Commission has prosecuted Canadian citizens for publicly stating their belief that homosexuality is a sin. It attempted to prosecute journalist Mark Steyn and Macleans magazine after receiving a complaint that he was painting an unfair portrayal of Muslims in an article published in 2007 (you can read a bit more about the CHRC issues here). This is but one example.

The parallels that Lutzer addresses—increased government control in economic issues (such as propping up major corporations that are on the verge of bankruptcy due to gross mismanagement) and the devaluing of human beings through the legalization of abortion, the “evolved” form of tolerance that is used to bully people into silence out of fear of being called a ‘bigot” for disagreeing with a lifestyle, sexual orientation or religious viewpoint (unless it’s Christianity) and pushes to see moral absolutes become relative preferences in the school system—paint a disturbing picture.

Focus on the Cross

It’s tempting for many Christians to respond to these issues in a way that is profoundly unhelpful. The “we’re gonna take this nation back for God!” approach. The problem is, political ballyhoo doesn’t work. It never has.

[W]ithout the cross, we pound a nail into our coffin! There is a danger that we become so overburdened with social/political agendas that our message is lost amid our many cultural skirmishes. The church has always faced the temptation to modify the Gospel or make it secondary to a given political, philosophical, or cultural agenda. When this happens, Christians have exposure to the culture, but the cross does not. . . . In the evangelical community, psychology is substituted for theology and cheap grace has replaced what Bonhoeffer described as “costly grace.” . . . . We are self-absorbed rather than God-absorbed. (pp. 135-137)

So how should Christians respond? By focusing on the cross of Christ.

We are coming to a time when Christianity in the western world might actually face real persecution, like it has in every other culture for centuries. Lutzer admonishes readers,

As Christians we can welcome an assault on our freedoms as long as we see this conflict as an opportunity to bear an authentic witness to Christ. . . . We must be confident that Christ will set the record straight. (pp. 140-141).

Lutzer practices what he preaches. He never demonizes those he opposes. His arguments are genuinely humble and pastoral. He seeks to bear witness to the grace of Christ and be salt and light in a world that desperately needs it. His admonishment is difficult, but one not to shy away from.

Read When a Nation Forgets God. Wrestle with the implications; be challenged by it—and consider how you will respond. Will it be with silence or with grace and humility as your eyes are focused on Jesus?

Recommended

This book was provided for review by Moody Press.

Get new content delivered to your inbox

  • http://www.aholyexperience.com Ann Voskamp@Holy Experience

    As a fellow Canadian, I find your review very helpful — yes, to focus on the Cross of Christ.

    I deeply appreciate Lutzer — thank you for this thoughtful review.

    All’s grace,
    Ann

    • http://hardwords.wordpress.com Aaron Armstrong

      Thanks for reading, Ann – I hope all’s well. God bless.

  • http://covenantoflove.net Derek

    I have had this book floating around in my about for a few weeks now, and desperately trying to get to it (in the midst of a pile of other reads).

    Thanks for your thoughts, when I read the book I’ll keep your analysis in mind.

  • http://covenantoflove.net Derek

    *”about” should be “bag”… fingers move too fast sometimes.

  • http://hardwords.wordpress.com Aaron Armstrong

    I think you’ll really appreciate it, Derek. Lutzer is terrific.

  • http://www.maxgrace.com maxgrace

    I’d like to second the statement that Erwin Lutzer practices what he preaches. I’ve worked along side him many times, and he is always charitable and gracious, even toward those with whom he disagrees. This book’s message isurgently needed in our day. Thanks for the review.

  • http://hardwords.wordpress.com Aaron Armstrong

    Thanks for reading, Bill – I’m grateful for men like Dr. Lutzer who model speaking the truth in love. I only hope I will get there someday.

  • Pingback: Looking Back: My Favorite Books of 2010 | Blogging Theologically | Jesus, Books, Culture, & Theology()

  • Boyd Jahnke

    Just a side note ~ Dr. Lutzer started out in Canada as well.